Home · Illustrations
Three households, none of them you
The people below are invented so the arithmetic can wear a name. Their salaries, rents and catalogues are round on purpose. If a figure happens to match your life, that is a coincidence, not a recommendation. Replace every number before you act, and read the backing notes on dividends, rent, ISAs, pensions and royalties.
Truro · employed
Maya fills the wrapper before she hunts a yield
Maya is 34 and works as a radiographer. Her salary is £42,000. She is inside the basic-rate band, once the personal allowance is used. Her employer pays 5% of qualifying earnings into a workplace pension if she pays 5%. She has no card debt. She rents a room in a shared house and keeps £4,000 in an easy-access account, which is about three months of her essential bills.
A forum has told her to buy four UK shares with dividend yields above 7%. The trailing yields are real. Two of the companies have already frozen the dividend once in five years. She does not have an ISA.
The desk’s illustration, not an instruction: she takes the employer match, because declining it would throw away part of her pay. She opens a stocks and shares ISA and directs £400 a month into a single global equity fund, income or accumulation, inside the ISA so the choice is about cash flow rather than tax. At £400 a month she uses £4,800 of the £20,000 allowance. She does not borrow to use the rest. The 7% shares can wait until she can explain, in a sentence, why she wants those businesses rather than the several thousand inside the fund.
If she later has a bonus, the unused ISA room is the first door, not a new brokerage account outside the shelter. Dividend tax at 10.75% is avoidable here. Paying it for the pleasure of a large yield on a handful of names is a hobby. Hobbies are allowed. They should be named as hobbies.
St Buryan · a couple, late careers
Helen and Tom price a cottage against a pension
Helen is 58 and Tom is 61. They own the house they live in, with no mortgage. A cottage nearby is on the market at £300,000. They could buy it with savings and a modest buy-to-let loan, and a local agent has guessed £1,400 a month rent in a good year. Both are higher-rate taxpayers. They also have unused annual allowance in their pensions.
The purchase, if it is an additional dwelling in England, carries the stamp duty illustration from the rental note: about £20,000. That cash is gone at completion. A year with £16,800 of rent, £2,500 of ordinary costs and £6,000 of interest does not leave £8,300 to spend. Under Section 24 the interest is not deducted. If the whole rental profit sits in the higher-rate band, the tax can consume a startling share of the cash, in the same pattern as the £18,000 example on the rental page. A void in January, which is not rare on a holiday-adjacent lane, changes the year again.
The alternative sketch: they put a slice of the same savings into pensions, within the annual allowance and within what they are allowed to contribute given their earnings. Higher-rate relief means a £1 contribution can cost 60 pence of net pay, depending on how the scheme takes the money, and the capital is locked until the access age. Tom is close to that age. Helen has longer. Locking is a feature if the money was meant for later life, and a defect if it was meant for a roof they might need to repair in their own home.
The illustration does not pick a winner. It refuses the sentence “bricks are safer”. Safer than what, after stamp duty, after a boiler, after tax relief they would otherwise have claimed? They write both columns on one page before they book a second viewing. If they still want the cottage because they like being landlords, that is a reason. It is not the reason the advert gave them.
Bristol · a small catalogue
Idris and the trading allowance
Idris is 29 and designs print templates in the evenings. This tax year buyers have paid £7,400 through a marketplace. The platform kept £890 in fees. Software and a printer cost him £1,100. He has a day job at £31,000. He has not registered as self-employed because a friend said the trading allowance makes small sales invisible.
The allowance is £1,000 of gross income. He is past it. He needs to be in Self Assessment for the trade. He then chooses. Use the £1,000 allowance and lose the right to deduct the £1,100 of costs, or ignore the allowance and deduct the costs, including the platform fees if they are his expenses rather than a reduction already reflected in turnover. He checks the marketplace statement so he does not deduct a fee that never entered his turnover figure. Deducting costs is the better arithmetic here. The allowance would have been lovely at £900. It is not a blanket.
VAT is nowhere near. A company is nowhere near. He opens a separate account so the template money is not the money for groceries, and he puts a sentence on the product page if he ever recommends a tool that pays him. The catalogue sold while he was on a train last month, which is the first time the word passive has earned its keep. It will not sell if he stops making new work forever. He keeps the day job, takes his employer pension match, and does not compare a lucky month with a dividend yield.
How to reuse the method
- Write the cash that actually moves, after fees, voids and interest.
- Write the tax on that cash under the rule that applies to the owner, not the rule from a book published in 2016.
- Write the hour of the week the project still needs. Price the hour as if you had to hire someone.
- Put the pension match and the unused ISA allowance in the other column, even if they are boring.
- Decide. If you cannot explain the decision without the word “guaranteed”, you are not done.